Fasting · 4 min read
Fasting Protocols Compared: 16:8, 18:6, 20:4, OMAD, 5:2
Try it: Intermittent Fasting Window Planner — Get a full-day schedule that puts your eating window where your training actually is.
Every fasting protocol involves the same trade-off: a longer fast means a shorter eating window, and a shorter window leaves fewer meals to fit in your food and protein. The useful question is not which one "burns more fat". It is which one your day, training and protein target can support.
The five at a glance
| Protocol | Eating window | Realistic meals | What it costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14:10 | 10 hours | 3 | Almost nothing; mainly cuts out late-night eating |
| 16:8 | 8 hours | 2 to 3 | Skipping breakfast or eating an early dinner |
| 18:6 | 6 hours | 2 | Morning training and social meals become awkward |
| 20:4 | 4 hours | 1 to 2, close together | Protein and hard training both become a strain |
| OMAD (23:1) | about 1 hour | 1 | One very large meal; hardest to work around other people |
| 5:2 | Normal 5 days | Normal | Two non-consecutive low-calorie days each week |
The first five use daily time windows. 5:2 works differently: you eat normally five days a week and cut to roughly a quarter of normal intake on two non-consecutive days, creating a weekly deficit. It can suit people whose days are too unpredictable for a fixed window, but those two days are genuinely hard.
What the evidence does and does not say
Be cautious of anyone who confidently ranks these. Here is what holds up:
- Fasting works by lowering intake. When total calories are matched, intermittent fasting shows no consistent advantage over an ordinary calorie deficit. It is a way to eat less without counting, not a metabolic trick.
- Evidence for daily windows is mostly about 16:8. The shorter-window versions (18:6, 20:4, OMAD) are familiar conventions, but the sources behind this site do not rank them by results or by how long people stick with them. Claims that "OMAD loses the most weight and is abandoned fastest" are plausible, not established. Treat them as reasoning, not data.
- Hunger usually settles into a fixed schedule. That is common experience rather than a measured figure, but it is why it makes sense to hold one window steady for a few weeks before judging it, rather than cycling through three in a month.
The protein arithmetic that actually decides it
Illustrative example (not a real client). Take a 32-year-old man, 175 cm and 80 kg, training three to five days a week. The Mifflin-St Jeor equation puts his maintenance at about 2,695 kcal a day. At a steady 0.25% of bodyweight a week, he is aiming for roughly 2,475 kcal, a deficit of about 220 kcal. For strength training the protein range is 1.6 to 2.0 g/kg, so 128 to 160 g a day. Switching protocol does not change any of that. It changes how the protein needs to be divided:
| Window | Typical meals | Protein per meal |
|---|---|---|
| 16:8 | 3 | about 43 to 53 g |
| 18:6 | 2 | about 64 to 80 g |
| OMAD | 1 | 128 to 160 g |
Usual per-meal guidance is around 0.25 to 0.4 g per kg, roughly 20 to 32 g for this man, and spreading protein across the day beats loading it into one or two sittings. Some newer work suggests that very large single doses are not simply wasted, so the numbers above are not impossible. They are simply easier to hit at 16:8 than at OMAD, and there is no second meal to save the day if the one meal goes wrong. Work out your own range with the protein calculator; if you are going to run a short window anyway, see the protein timing guide.
How to choose
- When do you train, and how hard? Heavy lifting four or more days a week fits 14:10 or 16:8; easy cardio is more forgiving. A tight window pushes sessions outside it. See fitting the window around training.
- What is your protein target? The higher it is, the more meals you need. Over about 150 g a day, a window of four hours or less becomes a logistics project.
- Which meal is non-negotiable? If it is dinner with your family, the window ends late and everything else needs to fit around that.
- How predictable is your week? Shift work and unpredictable childcare favour the gentler end (14:10 or 16:8) anchored to waking, or 5:2, over a rigid short window.
A sensible path: start one step easier than you think you need, hold it for about four weeks, then decide whether to tighten it by two hours. Moving from 16:8 to a shorter window will not rescue a stalled diet. When weight loss stalls, first check whether the deficit is still real and whether protein is still landing. Tightening a window that is already costing you protein adds a second problem to the first. The window is not the deficit: a short window with two very large meals can still add up to maintenance.
Where these protocols stop being a good idea
None of this is for everyone. Avoid daily fasting windows, or speak to a clinician first, if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have had an eating disorder, are under 18, or take insulin or other blood-sugar medication, where fasting carries a real risk of low blood sugar. Women who are lean, training hard or cutting hard should be especially cautious about low energy availability, which can disturb the menstrual cycle and bone health, and are better off starting at 14:10 or 16:8. If you notice sleep disruption, persistent fatigue or cycle changes, widen the window. And if a protocol has you bingeing when it opens, it is not working for you, however tidy it looks on paper.
The fasting window planner will lay any of these against your actual training time, and the TDEE calculator sets the calorie target they all have to serve.
Common questions
Which protocol burns the most fat?
Over weeks, it is whichever produces the largest sustained deficit, which for most people is the one they can keep doing, not the strictest.
Can I change protocols day to day?
You can, but hunger settles into a schedule it can predict, so holding one window for a few weeks usually works better than switching.
Is 16:8 better than eating normally in a deficit?
Not when calories are matched. It is a way to eat less without counting, so it helps if it makes that easier for you and does nothing if it does not.
Read next
- How to Fit a Fasting Window Around Your Training Your training hour is usually fixed, while your eating window can move. Timetables for early, lunchtime, evening, twice-a-day and shift-work trainers.
- Protein Timing and Short Eating Windows What protein timing is really worth, how to split your day across meals, and how to hit your target inside a short eating window.
- How to Break a Fast Without Undoing the Day Most fasting plans fall apart in the two hours after the window opens. What to put in the first meal, how big to make it, and when to ease in.